Showing posts with label WoTC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WoTC. Show all posts

More Thoughts on 5E Adventures


I was watching a video by RPGrandPa Tabletop comparing TSR and WotC adventures and it got me thinking about 5E adventure design. He mentions the big issues that bugged me, overly long, 1-10th level, something of a railroad that requires nudging and pushing to keep the story on track. I understand why the Wizards did all this (simplified product line is likely the big one) but if you keep tot that model you could still sharpen it a bit.

Using Storm King's Thunder as an example. The module starts with a disposable section you toss if your characters enter at 6th level. Then some good stuff of Giants attacking a city (repeated three times but you pick only one so you can repeat the module later and have it be different). Then a series of fetch-quests designed to help the players get high enough level to actually fight the giants. 

I think a better module layout would follow the way player characters level-up using a sub-class for features at certain levels except in this case it would an Adventure Module provide semi-linked adventures at certain levels and ignoring the levels between. Then Support Modules fill in the levels in between. 
Adventure Modules would have to be roughly stabilize on which levels they cover but that shouldn't be so hard. This allows campaigns to have variety (not Giants again?), ensures every campaign is different (especially if Support Modules only covered a Tier of play so you had to get a couple to match the length of the main module), and makes it so the DM doesn't have to read the entire Adventure Module before starting play.
 
These Support Modules would be something like Tales from the Yawning Portal but with adventures specifically selected/designed to fill in levels left blank by the Adventure Module. 

Some current adventures clearly wouldn't work with this system like the one I propose such as out of the Abyss in which you start you off as prisoners in the underdark in the first part and then return to attack the underdark in the second part when you are higher level. In that case, well I'm not gonna miss that one.

Anyway that was the idea, not fully developed but I think it would work better than what they are doing.

The Crazy Way Wizards chooses Products to make

 So my characters went to Neverwinter and it got really sandboxy very quickly which I like, which they like, it's all good. The problem is we're playing Roll20 and you really need battlemaps. I found a nice map of Castle Never, and another of the Moonstone Masks location. Other generic maps worked for what I needed. But it made me think, Neverwinter has been around for a few decades now and there isn't a proper product with interior maps of the major buildings (same with Waterdeep). Back in the day they had books of generic battlemaps, why not have a book full of Neverwinter maps? Another book of Waterdeep maps. I don't even care if you include Factions or an adventure, just a book of maps. 

Now we are in the world of VTTs I bet they'd sell a lot of that sort of thing. Back during 4E when combat sort of needed a Battlemap I bet they'd sell a lot of that sort of thing. But you can't sell it if you don't make it. 

Thoughts on Alignment

Sort of continuing from Friday's Best of the Web post, part of the Wizards of the Coat policies was to suggest a change in alignments so that these races are not always evil. I've always ignored Alignments for Player Characters but find them occasionally useful for NPC and monsters, still I'd never noticed the alignments changed over time.

Baddie Alignment Through the Editions
Race
1E
3E
5E
Drow Elves 
CE 
Usually NE
NE
Dueger Dwarves
LE 
Often LE
LE
Goblin
LE 
Usually NE
NE
Hobgoblin
LE
Usually LE
LE
Ogre
CE 
Usually CE
CE 
Orc
LE 
Often CE
CE

I find it especially interesting that 3E added Usually and Often to a number of alignments. I don't know if I read it somewhere or if I was just a rebel as a kid but I'd always assumed a race wasn't gonna be 100% all one alignment.

New Head of D&D RPG Team?

According to Nerd Immersion WoTC now has put Ray Winninger in charge of the D&D design team. As far as I can tell nobody else is reporting this so who knows. Anyway Ray Winninger is the guy that did the Dungeoncraft essays for Dragon Magazine. I don't remember being blown away with anything unique or creative in those essays. I'll have to reread I guess.
Nerd Immersion would create a 5.5 version of the game repackaging class and monsters into a new players handbook and a new monster book. Not a bad idea to tidy up the product line but it makes me think of Avalon Hill's RuneQuest in which they repackaged RuneQuest products from just a year before and it felt like they had nothing new for a year or two. They lost momentum. Still the idea isn't bad if it didn't take to long or too many resources but I'd keep that on the back burner.
So what would I do? Nothing extreme. 5e is popular, don't fix what isn't broken but two ideas do pop into my head.
  1. I'd move heaven and Earth to make a 5E version of Greyhawk and that Greyhawk would be far more Gonzo Sci-fi fantasy to differentiate it from Forgotten Realms or whatever worlds WoTC is selling now. I'd create scenario packs for that setting. Combinations of old modules sold under one title the way they are doing it now, but I'd put them together sandbox style. Start with the Keep as a base of operations and drop a dozen modules (with backstories rewritten as necessary) within range and include notes on how to properly use story hooks and let the players have some agency in selecting where they want to adventure. This would hopefully set it off from the pseudo-adventure paths they've been doing and really show a different style of play. Oh, and I'd get Errol Otus as the lead artist to ensure Greyhawk visually stood out from the vanilla Realms.
  2. I'd put together a book on House Rules, Reskinning, and DIY advice. This really is the heart of D&D to many and I don't think TSR or Wizards has ever directly addressed it. They should encourage DIY. I don' think it'll rob sales, in fact it might do the opposite. Right now you don't buy this or that because you'll never use it, but with a DIY attitude you might buy it knowing you can pick it apart to get interesting NPC, borrow the map for something else, and borrow bits of that backstory. DMs pick this up on their own, it's somewhat natural if you've got a long campaign campaign and you have to feed the creativity but Im sure the designers at Wizards have ideas that might be worthwhile.
Beyond that I don't know.

Sandbox Campaigns and the Kingdom of Stormwind

Personally I think a Sandbox approach to setting works the best. Back in the day when I used Harn and so much was mapped out it was insanely...