Bestiary - Thoughts on Undead Part 1

Undead in Pathfinder and D&D seem completely wrong. Strict categorization steels the mystery of the undead, at least of ghosts. And despite the strict categorization there is zero consistency behind any of it. Lastly some undead are created by such unlikely combinations events it would seem unlikely that more than one such undead would ever appear. So many undead in Pathfinders long list of Undead are entirely pointless and stupid and I'd be surprised if anybody every used them. Having said that, here are my thoughts on different Undead in the Pathfinder.

One thing Pathfinder does have is a wonderful variety of feats for the undead. In time I'll peace through them and put together tables for Ghosts to provide a nice unpredictable variety of effects that occur. I think the unpredictability is a big part of making Ghosts scary.

Undead

Undead are spirits in the mundane world. They may be free floating ghosts or animated flesh of some sort. A spirit that animates other things (statues for example) are known as constructs. As spirits they are effected by a Cleric's Banish ability. The intelligence of the undead depends upon the spirit  but the older undead should become a bit more insane as far as mortals judge such things.

The idea of undead is to create truly scarey areas in tombs, with guardians that can defend a location forever without food or even air.

Ghosts

Ghosts are spirits of the dead. They linger back and forth between the spirit world and the mundane world unable to move on to their final destination. There are two main types but these are each defined by a number of tables.

  • Haunt - An incorporeal spirit.
  • Remainer - A spirit given physical form (made of ectoplasm although that doesn't matter) so that the Remainer can touch and interact with things as if they were alive although they can't be killed like a normal mortal. Clint Eastwood's unnamed character in High Plains Drifter would be an example

Table 1: Cause of Death
1d6
Cause
01
Accident
02
Drowning
03
Hanging
04
Murder
05
Neglect
06
Suicide

Table 2: Can't Move On
1d6
Until
01
Forgiveness
02
Buried Properly
03
Debt Repaid
04
Expose Truth
05
Return Item
06
Vengeance
Table 3: Haunt Type

1d6
Until
01
Human, Former Identity Clear
02
Human, Former Identity Unclear
03
Humanish 
04
Spirit, Ectoplasmic human form
05
Spirit, Ectoplasmic non-human form
06
Spirit, Insubstantial
Table 4: Other Details (roll twice)
1d6
Until
01
Covered in Gore/Worms
02
Floats above ground/Lacks legs/feet
03
Headless/Faceless
04
Insatiably Hungry
05
White Clothes, Hair, or skin
06
Screaming

Note - The art above is copyright Don Kenn who is one of the only people to draw truly creepy looking ghosts. I make no claims to it beyond loving his work and will remove it if asked.




Bestiary - Thoughts on Constructs Part 2

Metal Constructs

Metal statues that have been animated. Possibly a suit of animated plate armor. They typically have the construction glyphs on the inside. the statues are typically humanoid or beast but the effect is the same as they rarely use weapons and if they do it will be made of the same material as the construct itself.
  • Golem, Bronze - Statue made of bronze. Common in classic age societies, often painted. Was brass but why? The Greeks actually made bronze statues and that weathered greening bronze looks really cool.
  • Golem, Gold - Statue made of gold. Typically found in tombs and crypts where large amounts of gold won't draw undo attention. Gold is soft as far as metals go so its limbs can be cut off even if the thing is hard to kill. Also gold has a lower melting point that most other metals so gold golems are vulnerable to fire.
  • Golem, Iron - Statue made of iron. Iron is expensive and useful for making armor and weapons so statues of iron are rare except to decorate tombs but an iron golem would be very difficult to fight and i can imagine weapons getting blunt and breaking.
  • Gorgon - An iron bull is used in many chaos executions. Sacrifices are put inside and a fire is then started beneath. Occasionally this causes the spirit of the dead to possess the bull to prevent it from being dragged into the afterlife. I think the iron bull Gorgon from D&D fits as a construct better than some magical beast roaming the world.
  • Serpent, Iron - Statue of a serpent made of iron. Created primarily by snake worshipers and Naga.

Plant/Wood Constructs

Naturally constructs made of wood and plants are very vulnerable to fire. Still they are popular among the Fey and nearly invisible to see in a forest when they are not moving.
  • Feyward Tree - A tree occupied by the spirit of an Elf.
  • Golem, Wood - A statue carved out of wood, assembled together out of wood pieces, or a dead tree with a spirit inside to animate. This is the kind of thing Druids might make to defend their groves.
  • Haunted Construct Scarecrow - Hoping to avoid the afterword occasionally a spirit will possess a person or body, in this case the silly beast animated a scarecrow.
  • Serpent - A spirit trapped in a stick. The stick may be carved like a serpent or not but it will act like one and quickly break off any branches that inhibit it's slithering.
  • Wyrwood - Tiny wood golem used as a spy or messenger by Elves.

Stone Constructs

Stone Constructs are made of stone, and thus very difficult to damage. They can be made in humanoid or beast shape. They don't use weapons so any damage would be bashing damage. Typically they are statues but not necessarily.
  • Golem, Rubble - A pile of flagstones, masonry, bricks, boulders, or even stones animated so as to act as a single golem. Because they are not truly united any piercing or slashing damage just slips between the pieces and any blunt weapon damage is doubled as pieces are knocked clear.
  • Golem, Stone - An animated stone statue, usually marble but stone is not unheard of. A statue that looks/acts like a structural column is known as a caryatid column, one dedicated to protecting a city is known as a cephalophore, a gargoyle on a building so animated is known as a gargoyle. Sometimes a stone golem will just be a head animated to watch over a location.

Science Fiction/Steampunk Constructs

  • Aballonian - Aballonians are intelligent, self-modifying constructs. I don't know what Aballonian means and it reminds me too much of abalone so the name has to change.
  • Brain Cylinder - A brain in a jar. I love brains and/or heads in jars that can communicate to players. The undead version I call a semi-lich.
  • Golem, Alchemical - Primitve clockwork.
  • Golem, Clockwork Golum - Steam and/or gear powered robots animated by a spirit.
  • Octopod Mechanic Drone - Octopus-like repair robot.
  • Robot - Not a construct with an animating spirit so much as a robot with artificial intelligence. Robots come in a multitude of sizes and shapes as they are usually created with a specific task in mind. Many are not even humanoid as treads are often more appropriate for certain tasks.
Note - The art above is copyright Stefan Poag. I make no claims to it beyond loving his work and will remove it if asked.

Bestiary - Thoughts on Constructs Part 1

Constructs are the perfect monster as they can sit around waiting patiently for the characters to arrive yet I rarely use them in my campaigns because they are so bland. So I decided to work up how things work and go over the constructs in Pathfinder only to find nearly half were repetitions of other constructs, overly specific, or just terrible. I trimmed and trimmed and organized primarily by the material of the construct.

My idea is constructs are animated by placing/trapping a portion of spirit into an object and as such they are effected by a Cleric's Banish ability. Also this gives the thing personality. if the thing being animated has anything even remotely resembling a mouth or eyes the process of animating it will also give it site, hearing, and speech. Constructs should be more like the teapot and plates in Beauty and the Beast then some mindless automatons. The intelligence of the construct depends upon the spirit and the mobility and attack depend upon the item used to create the construct.

The idea of constructs is to create truly magical areas in tombs and Wizarding schools with mundane items that are never caught sleeping, live virtually forever, and which can move, converse, or attack. Also constructs might make a nice place to store the spirit of a dead character until their body can be brought back, giving a player or two a very unique change of pace after a defeat.

I'll figure out the details on creating Constructs later.

Animated Objects

Animated object are any object that a wizard has trapped a spirit within. If there is anything remotely resembling eyes or a mouth they will take on that function. Because of this animated objects are often used as spies or to pass along messages. The ability to attack is also highly dependent upon the object that has been animated.
  • Abandoned Armory - Not just one item but a pile of armor and weapons animated as a single construct. The abandoned armory moves and attacks in a wave, like water, battering targets in a wave of weapons and mail. Typically an Abandoned Armory is found on a battlefield.
  • Amalgamation - Similar to an Abandoned Armory except the pile is chairs or tools or clothes and other mundane item animated into a single construct.
  • Animated Object, Colossal - An object the size of a ship.
  • Animated Object, Gargantuan - An object the size of a catapult.
  • Animated Object, Huge - An object the size of a wagon or rowboat.
  • Animated Object, Large - An object the size of a large table.
  • Animated Object, Medium - An object the size of a barrel.
  • Animated Object, Small - An object the size of a chair.
  • Animated Object, Tiny - An object the size of a plate, book, coin, or silverware.
  • Guardian Doll - A doll turned into a Construct, generally for use as a spy.
  • Tattoo Guardian - Animated tattoo, not sure what to do with this but I like the idea of moving tattoo.

Earth Constructs

Earth constructs can be sculpted by or founded by the wizard and as such come in a near infinite variety of forms. What marks them is they disintegrate when they take damage.
  • Golem, Clay - Large or medium sized clay construct. It could be humanoid or beast in shape, doesn't matter as the damage will be the same bashing blows of clay. Clay absorbs most damage particularly well as piercing and slicing weapons cut it but don't really damage it unless they slice a chunk off or something. A clay golem can become 100% invisible if it lies down in a bed of clay or river bottom.
  • Golem, Sand - Large or medium sized sand construct. It could be humanoid or beast in shape, doesn't matter as the damage will be the same bashing blows of sand. Cutting and stabbing weapons slice through the sand without causing damage while crushing weapons send the sand flying, reducing the golem in the process. A sand golem can become 100% invisible if it lies down in normal sand.
  • Homunculus - Tiny humanoid figure created from ash and blood and then animated to serve the creator. Usually the spirit of a dead minion is used to ensure loyalty.
  • Terra-cotta Warrior - Statues made of dried clay. The Warrior may be armed with normal weapons. Such golems are easily broken and shattered and are primarily used as skirmishers, to keep watch, or for cermonial reasons.
  • Terra-cotta Animal - An animal statue that is otherwise the same as a terra-cotta warrior. 

Flesh Constructs

Flesh constructs are too similar to undead and will be categorized along with them.

Holy Constructs

The other constructs are divided by their material, Holy Constructs can be made of different materials but are given their own heading because of their nature. Holy Constructs use volunteer spirits to fight on behalf of Law they cannot be Banished.
  • Angelic Guardian - A bronze, animated statue of an angel. The wings aren't enough to lift the heavy body but they are sharp and can serve as weapons.
  • Argent Warden - Animated armor and weapon covered in Holy Writings and animated.
  • Charnel God - A statue to a powerful servant of a Deity that has been possessed by that servant after death. Such statues often sit in temples for centuries with no sign of their status.
  • Cryptguard - A statue with a particularly anti-undead bent often placed in crypts to keep the dead down and living out.


Fantasy Heartbreaker - Beasts

If you make a rule-set you need monsters to make it feel complete. At least that's how I feel. Folks can choose to play in a monster free world, but they should at least have the option and telling them to use other game bestiaries is kind of lame.

I love bestiaries. I don't think I'm alone in that. I buy bestiaries I know I'll never use because I love flipping through them. I think I primarily love the art. Monster Manual had a ton of useful monsters so you pretty much needed it but I never liked most of the art. I appreciate how many beasts were illustrated, but the line weights were too light for my tastes and the cover was a confused mess. The AD&D Fiend Folio gets a lot of grief but the Russ Nicholson art was perfect, it was evocative, it had me using monsters that were otherwise a bit bland or gamey.

Then there is RuneQuest. The game I went to after AD&D. In RuneQuest 2 they only had a small selection of beasts and a lot of them weren't really illustrated. RuneQuest 3 barely tried in their Bestiary. They had the line weight problem and dumped multiple beasts into a single image which was made the book design cleaner but ensured every creature was tiny. The British version had a nice Bestiary but I didn't see that for decades, long after Chaosium and Games Workshop split up.

Beyond nice illustrations I've recently fallen for useful tables that help the GM use the beasts. I fell in love with a post by Tom Fitzgerald at Middenmurk called Bestiary of the Fabled Occident and can't wait until the book is available. Just take a look at one of the samples, nice image of the creature, lots of useful tables. It's just perfect. My only problem is the Header fonts are hard to read but that's a small thing.




I bought Peterson's Field Guide to Lovecraftian Horrors based on the images alone but the useful little bits and comparisons made the book fun. I've never played Call of Cthulhu but I certainly wanted to use a few of those monsters. Beautiful image, size comparisons, and details on the beast. It's a beauty.








The beautiful images and page color of the 5E monster manual apes this style. They have a nice division between mechanics (boxed off) and background that I like, but they don't really have the nice extra tables and info that elevate the info a bit beyond an encyclopedia entry that I'm talking about.

It also annoys me how most bestiaries are sort of cobbled together. I'm talking about older D&D (not sure about 5E) and Pathfinder 1 that seem to put the must have monsters in the first volume, then things get progressively worse as each additional bestiary comes out and they claw around for enough content with a few really solid monsters to ensure sales. I mean AD&D already provided the vast bulk of these monsters, look them over and come up with some organization. Maybe by CR so the books are very useful (yeah that'll cost some of the high end sales but I think they'd find most gamers are completes and would buy the books anyway); maybe by genre (Sword & Sorcery monsters vs Vanilla Fantasy Tolkien vs Earth Mythology).

So I came across Skerples Monster Overhaul. He included some of those useful tables. One article led to another and then another then to one called  OSR: The Monster Overhaul - Planning
 and another called OSR: Sharpening the Axe - How I Plan and Write RPG Books


and I realized I really needed to plan out my Bestiary. I need to merge similar beasts together to reduce the vast numbers and categorize the beasts. Categorizing is important as I believe undead should have a certain feel and it is easier to create that feel when they are all written as a group. Same with Constructs or Chaos or whatever. Then when I'm putting my bestiary together I can chop categories to get the right length and theme to a volume instead of chopping out individual beasts. I think the whole will be better that way. I might even put together an appendix or two of oddball stuff such as Pathfinders Clockwork Golems and Robots which don't really fit in most settings but might make for a really unique setting and/or Barrier Peaks style adventure.

So that's the idea anyway. Go over the Pathfinder beasts as the list there is so super-large and online in a useful way, and decide what I like and don't and group things together.

Bestiary - Thoughts on Beastiaries

Another thing that has always bugged me about various RPG beastiaries is that they are all do-it-yourself. Here are the dice to role to determine this and that. RuneQuest 2 at least provided the average number so that you could quickly create an average creature but nobody else has followed suit. 

A beastiary should have stat-blocks ready to go. Not just for the average but for big and small versions. If done correctly a GM could just transcribe or copy/paste the info and populate an adventure quickly, or just use the book on the fly.

As I've been thinking about the beastiary(s) I'd create it occured to me that i've grouped beasts together in two situations. (1) When the beasts were behaviorally the same even if they were drastically different. An example would be Canines. A Chihauha and a German Shepard behave basically the same except one can back up the threat more than the other so they'd need different statblocks. (2) When the beasts are basically the same but behave differently. My example here would be Elves. From a Statblock point of view the Wood Elf and Dark Elf are basically the same, but culturally (the part required when putting an adventure or campaign together) they are night and day. Still their weapon, armor, & spell choices would be different so a partial stat-block of that info for each type is probably warranted. Same with humans, Desert Nomads have a different culture from Civilized or Feudal humans, they'll have different weapons and armor and all that, but both will have the same 3d6 for every attribute when it comes to their stats.

Anyway that's been on my mind so I thought I'd write it out specifically before I go on.

Some thoughts on Charisma

Everybody treats CHA as a dump stat and I doubt anything I'll say here will change that but hopefully I'll provide a few nuggets worth considering. In my own fantasy heartbreaker I think CHA becomes a bit more important but its still gonna be a dump stat to some extent.

Back in the day CHA was good for determining how many hirelings a character could have and their morale, but few people delve constantly into dungeons these days and even fewer do so with small armies of hirings. Now, folks are running around the countryside or in urban settings playing politics and these are exactly the sort of places where CHA can shine.

CHA is not appearance
I'd like to get this out of the way straight on. CHA is not comeliness. We don't need a stat for appearance. Let every character be as beautiful or ugly as the player wants.

CHA as Social Network
NPCs are the lifeblood of any campaign. They are the interface the characters use to engage with the world and the GM has to create a metric shit ton of NPCs over the course of a campaign. Instead the GM should assign players the task of generating an NPC for each point of CHAr. If they have a 5 CHA they create 5 NPC, if they have an 18 CHA they create 18 NPC. These NPC don't need stats, just a name, maybe a basic personality, and how they know the character (family, same town, co-workers, etc).

The catch is that the players don't determine if the NPCs like their character or hate them. That's the GMs job (and that should be kept secret) and the lower the CHA the higher percentage of the NPC will dislike the character. Round down.

Table 1: NPC Table
CHA
Like/Dislike
03-05
1/2 hate, 1/2 dislike
06-10
1/2 dislike, 1/2 neutral
11-14
1/4 dislike, 1/2 neutral, 1/4 like
15-18
1/2 neutral, 1/2 actively like 
21+
Every likes

  • Hate - NPCs that hate will make a hobby out of planning the characters demise, spreading gossip, and generally being a shit. 
  • Dislike - NPCs that dislike are mostly indifferent but will grab a pitch-fork and join the mob going after the character if the opportunity came up. 
  • Neutral - NPCs that are neutral will probably remember the character if they are brought up in conversation. 
  • Like - NPCs that like the character are folks that will volunteer to help and will never have to check morale if accompanying the character.

The GM can then use this network of player created NPCs to have a friendlier helpful vibe for those with higher CHA and to have folks actively spitting on the shoes of those with low CHA.

CHA as Social Class
Nobles have high Charisma. They might be total fools but growing up giving orders to servants and such fills one with the confidence that is the core of Charisma. So instead of rolling social class separately (as in some games) we can simply state that anyone with a high CHA (say 15+) is of the noble class. Perhaps their father is a knight and they have no claims themselves, or they are a bastard, whatever. Medium CHA (10-14) are most likely townsmen. The upper end probably come from wealthy merchant families, the lower end are at least independent craftsmen that aren't constantly trampled by the system. Anyone below 10 CHA comes from poor or serf/slave background. They must kow-tow to survive on a daily basis and it is rare for a leader to appear among this lot.

If you break down the numbers you'll find this way out of whack compared to actual medieval social class percentages but it'll work in a game in which nearly everybody dumps their worst numbers into CHA.

CHA and Fame
CHA can also be used as a bellwether for fame. Unless one keep moving around the tales of ones accomplishments will spread and folks will start to recognize the character based on their appearance. A GM might consider making a CHA check (including level) each time a band of adventurers enters a new town. If the check succeeds someone in the town recognizes them. When that happens before long everyone will recognize them.

At this point the GM must determine the reaction. It is one thing to be recognized for a career of saving villages and stopping trouble, and another altogether for being known as the folks that nearly killed the king but slipped away before being caught.

Also any magical items should be added to the CHA score for this roll. Typically just a 1 or 2 is sufficient, you don't want to tally up and judge every magical item. Only the flashy ones need be counted.

Sandbox Campaigns and the Kingdom of Stormwind

Personally I think a Sandbox approach to setting works the best. Back in the day when I used Harn and so much was mapped out it was insanely...