What I'd Do, Warhammer Edition

Back in May 2019 Games Workshop was looking for a new CEO. I had some ideas of what I would do if I was CEO and re-reading them they were mostly crap. What I'd do now that I'm older and wiser i have some other ideas that may be mostly crap but...

I'd create a skirmish game. I know they already have a few like Mordheim to start with so most of the work is done. The problem is their previous skirmish games have been stand-alone. Buy it and Games Workshop never supported it. I'd support the game with campaigns full of modules like every RPG system does. This breaks down the cost of each, allows a stream of new products to draw attention, and means the newbie doesn't need a massive army to start playing as they do with Warhammer Fantasy Battle. For example: 

The Dwarven Vault campaign is about a Dwarven vault being besieged by Goblinoids. Each module would have 20ish miniatures. Different modules would cover different regions of the vault. The first could be fighting over the mines and crypts in the lower levels of the vault, a second is around the ore smelting furnaces, the third is fight in the great hall. So if you bought them in order you'd have a lot of mini's by the time you got to that big battle in the great hall. Each module would have some special tactical issues to deal with and a few additional miniatures. 

The Mordheim Campaign would do the same thing but use different parts of the city with different factions. The work has mostly been done on Mordheim already so this would be cheap and easy follow-up.

Continue that until you've given a taste of all of the major Warhammer Fantasy armies. Then when folks basically have built up a few armies over time the cost of putting together a Fantasy Army will be trivial.

I'd stop the silly lawfare Games Workshop has been waging against everybody (as if they own the term Space Marine, please) and release the skirmish game under the Creative Commons license and let others create content (knowing my, that is Games Workshop miniatures are the best and folks would buy them to play out these other games). Probably crazy but that's what I'd do.

Some thoughts on 5E

I was a little late getting into 5E. My players and I cut our teeth on AD&D so that is something to think about during this post. Also for the first few sessions every player wanted a fighter (the most popular character class in polls as well) which creates a somewhat unique dynamic. A group of four fighters, two of which are archers, provides a pretty devastating attack.

My players prefer to get increases in to hit rather than the fiddly benefits at each level. They were constantly reminding each other not to forget class features. It all felt meta gaming and I didn't like it. Also it adds a level of complexity to the GM who has to keep track of what they can do. This I think dates back to AD&D when your fighter got better at fighting, and there were no extras per level.

This next complaint is not a 5E issue but an issue with every game. After a particularly successful mission the players were the toast of the village they saved. Playing out the events of carousing are dull and awkward. Also going door to door looking for plot hooks as seems to be expected in Lost Mines of Phandelin is dull and stupid. It would be much better to mix the two. Have the players take out the Redbrand Ruffians and then while drinking the rumors come to them.  A Carousing mechanic would work easily enough handle the celebration and hand out rumors. Then the players can have a more targeted search for info the next day when sober again. Carousing tables were a fun idea but they are just under-used when used for experience (or just used for experience). 

Another one that is not strictly 5E, but... I thought I liked platform leveling. That is mission complete you go up a level. This avoids counting XP like a bookkeeper. I'm a GM not a bookkeeper! But we had a session where two players didn't make it. They may join half way into this next adventure. So do they go up when the group goes up, that doesn't seem fair.

Lastly, for now at least, 5E and Lost Mines level the PCs up too quickly. I think if the pace of leveling slowed down the players might get a chance to get use to their new Class Features each level instead of just collecting them and forgetting about them.

Some Thoughts on Roll20

We continue to have problems with the video and audio. It seems random. Everyone can hear everyone and then a lot of I can't hear Mike, Mike are you there. The new kid in the group says people use Discord at the same time to handle these problems. I've heard about Discord servers but never paid much attention so I'm gonna let him figure it out for all of us.

Roll20 has a problem with NPCs. If I try to roll Initiative for the NPC Cleric and then try to roll Initiative for the enemy Goblins it will often over-write the Clerics initiative with the new roll. Closing and opening the Goblin Character sheet right before I roll their initiative seems to work but it shouldn't require that.  I also not sure I like that all Goblins share the same initiative in the Initiative tracker, I'd at least like the option to split the goblins into two groups and have each roll initiative. 

I really don't like that all Goblins share the same sheet (and all the ruffians share, and all the Orcs share) and have the same weapons, armor, and HP. This is really an issue with 5E and the way Lost Mines was literally translated exactly as written and it would have been nice to mix up the weapons and armor and hit points. 

The group went into Cragma castle, while it was still daylight out, hoping to catch some Orcs asleep. The Dynamic Lighting for Roll20 isn't really set up to handle light on the outside coming in. Or I simply don't know how to do it which is very likely. So I have a Dwarf NPC with a light that I moved around outside to make light come through windows and such. Hardly ideal but serviceable.

We found out that if you roll a critical hit the result shows in green which is really nice. Also we figured out how to turn on automatically roll damage and critical hit damage which is also very nice.

A few years ago I read a blog post called Dungeon Brawls about having encounters pile on instead of waiting in their rooms for the players. I really liked this and Roll20 makes this super easy for a GM to manage. The GM just has to be careful to not overwhelm the players. That means prep them, if necessary, about tactical consideration like choke points and difficult terrain and such so they can use it to their advantage. Also keeping an eye on HPs so they don't get wiped out without a chance. It really makes for a funner, and more believable combat when enemy reinforcements start arriving.

Don't Play the Sheet...

Skerpies at Coins and Scrolls once said this about the Glog (a game with features per level like 5E).
In play, class features and abilities don't actually come up as often as you'd think.
I've read a lot of comparisons to OSR play that talk about not playing the sheet and this sounded about right to me. Now I've GM'd a few sessions of 5E and found my old AD&D gang doesn't look at the sheets during play (except to find where to click their attack/damage/init which on Roll20 are done by clicking the sheet). 

I had to remind my players about the Second Wind and Action Surge features (after the battle when they almost lost two PCs). This makes me appreciate Lamentations and other Basic variants that just give you a better to hit, or better skills or whatever, and leave the rest up to the player as it seems the problem will get worse as they get additional features each level. Also the features feel a bit video-gamey.


Session 3: Phandelin

The players made it to Phandelin, turned in the wagon and goods for some cash. Turned over a bugbear head, checked into the inn and listened for rumors and such. Learned mostly about the Redband Ruffians. Visited the retired adventurer/apple farmer and decided to pop over to the Taphouse and see the Redband to judge them with their own eyes. A fight ensued and one of the Redband raced off while the group cleaned up the street and prepared to defend the taphouse against a retribution attack. That's when we cut for the day.

The module doesn't mention anything about revenge attacks. The assumption is the party will come into conflict with the Redband gang at the taphouse or elsewhere and finish them off? Or charge immediately into the Redband hangout which would be daft. The module would be better if it gave defensive values for different buildings (with the mining company being the best) and had the possibility of hunkering down for a counter-attack as a possibility. Such a thing should also include what happens to the town if the PCs head for the hills to avoid a counter-attack.

The info in the town section is not organized for the DM very well. I applaud them for putting a little urban adventer into the starter set It would be better to have each NPC listed in a printable roster with roleplay notes, statblock and what they know/rumors/sidequests. Then the town info would be tighter and the DM could have all the NPC info up at the same time. They also need a random encounters table. This is a great place to introduce the concept even if its just who's walking about.

A large number of the encounters in town are womenfolk. For a frontier town with goblins and orcs around that seems odd but it's never mentioned why. Are the men all miners out in the hills? Were a large number of men killed? Is there something about the Shrine of Luck that drew a lot of women to the area? Or did the designers just want to have more women NPCs and didn't really think about the repercussions? or did I miss something?

NPC, especially Goblins should be given names/descriptors. Really anything that will help the GM describe the NPC (one-eye, three fingers, Short sword goblin, etc) so the players can indicate who they want to attack instead of just 'the Goblin in front of Bjorn'. Instead they are all functionally clones with the same weapons and everything. I think using the same stat block is a nice savings in space and all but it wouldn't have hurt Wizards to make Weak Goblin, Goblin, and Strong Goblin and give them different HP and AC. Roll20 should have added to this by changing the weapons and armor on the different goblins and giving each a different character sheet. As is all encounters in a group share the same character sheet which means they roll group initiative, otherwise one initiative roll overwrites the next. Each can be given a different character sheet, I'm pretty sure, but they didn't set up Lost Mines that way (at least the Cragmore Hideout). Its nice how you can roll for weapon hits from the character sheet but the NPCs in Lost Mines are not set up to roll damage from the sheet the way players are which is lame. 

When you show up at an Inn the DM shouldn't be told to look at the game rules for pricing. Again this was probably to save space but it's a hassle. Even if the hardcopy couldn't do it right they should have done better in the Roll20 version.

Also in Roll20 its very visual. The module doesn't need building interiors but for Roll20 they really should have them.

Roll20 initiative needs some work. If a player has two character sheets up and they touch one it becomes active, then if they click initiative on the second it rolls initiative for the first. The first touch should make the sheet active, then a second touch would roll initiative. This would be intuitive and not accidentally overwrite another characters initiative. Also clicking on a token should bring up the Character sheet right away, the fuddy controls should be a second click since you rarely use them.

Lastly having a frontier town with a gang defined by red is a bit to Tombstone. To really make this work they should have given each member of the gang a bit of personality and mixed them in with the random encounters table (that they should have included but didn't) and had the players get to see them being dicks instead of just hearing about it. Show don't tell, that sort of thing.

That's all for now, it was a short session but a good one.

 

Game Design - Mini Dragon Slayer

So I have a degree in Graphic Design (never used professionally) and a career in Technical Writing so I developed some kind of sickness in which I write and rewrite games. So many games are full of unnecessary and often confusing stuff. So many sentences are passive, or tangled, or generally awkward, so I try to see if I can make them better. I'd like to think that I usually do but then toss the results.

Then I came across a challenge on Venger Satanis' blog. He has a game called Crimson Dragon Slayer and he's recently cut it down to 3 pages and challenged anyone who wanted to format it. I took up the challenge, he sent me the Word file and and hour later I had hacked together a nice little game. 

I used art by Kim Diaz Holm, who makes incredible art that he releases under the Creative Commons license with attribution. He has a Youtube channel so you can see him create art from scratch, it's amazing.

I doubled the page count but its still a clean little game that I think would be good to include with modules and such that ordinarily require one own an RPG. I sent it to him and he seemed to like it, he gave me a free pdf for participating, and was generally agreeable about the whole thing. He also said I could post it or change it or do whatever I wanted with it, so I edited a bit more (removed some art and cut a few bits that seemed Cha'alt specific) and got it to 4 pages (2 pages of content as 1-4 is the title page, and 4-4 is the credits).

The main way the game is cut so short was ditching attributes and leaning on other games for spells and monsters. This works for a beer & pretzels pick-up game, or for a game bundled for free with a module. I might follow this up with some kind of Spell book crafted from the Glog. So here is the core game.

Mini Dragon Slayer


Session 2: Cragmaw Hideout continued

One player missing so we had his PC hang back as an NPC. The rolls balanced out this time and we had one near death and one PC that couldn't hit to save his life. Still the YouTube guy that said Lost Mines is brutal had a very different group because 5E is so forgiving. Perhaps he's a Gen Z. 

Our kid said "his generation could not be as detailed as we are when approaching a dangerous situation."

Maybe that had something to do with it. They went in with military precision, and scouting, and old school tactics like we used to do. I was lenient because the sound of the stream covered most of the talk. still, if you weren't killed in a single blow it would be hard to die. I mean Roll20 auto-generated Elf started with 2 healing potions and Warriors get a Second Wind and even a short rest brings you back up almost the whole way if you're first level.

I upgraded to the Dynamic lighting and that was worth it. It still will take some getting used to, Tokens fill out the full 5 foot square so they don't hide as well as I'd like. Still lots of fun. Next on to Phandalin, probably.

Temple of the Damned, the Backup Campaign

During my current campaign I have four regular players. I'm willing to go forward with 3 out of 4 present but if we drop to 2 we'd s...